iGaming

Kalshi and Montana Agree to Drop Cross-Complaints Over Prediction Market Dispute

Kalshi and the State of Montana have jointly agreed to dismiss their federal lawsuits against each other, ending a legal confrontation that began when state regulators accused the prediction market operator of offering unlicensed sports wagering. Under the agreement, Montana has committed to pause enforcement of its gambling laws against the company while a related matter remains pending before the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

Background of the Dispute

The conflict originated in March 2025, when the Montana Gambling Control Division issued a cease-and-desist letter to Kalshi, asserting that the company’s sports-related event contracts constituted gambling activity under state law. Kalshi later stated that Montana gaming representatives had reversed course on a non-enforcement understanding reached in 2025, which the company argued necessitated legal action.

After receiving a second cease-and-desist order, Kalshi filed a federal lawsuit against Montana Attorney General Austin Knudsen and state gambling regulators, seeking a declaratory judgment that its federally regulated event contracts were not subject to state gambling regulation. The company has consistently maintained that, as a Designated Contract Market overseen by the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), its markets operate under exclusive federal jurisdiction.

Terms of the Dismissal

The joint dismissal follows a recent Ninth Circuit ruling favorable to Kalshi’s position that prediction market contracts fall within the federal regulatory framework. In exchange for Kalshi withdrawing its declaratory judgment action, Montana has agreed not to pursue enforcement action while the appellate process continues. The arrangement effectively pauses the state-level dispute without resolving the underlying legal question of whether sports event contracts are securities-style derivatives or gambling products.

Broader Industry Context

The Montana resolution arrives amid a wider wave of regulatory and litigation activity involving prediction market operators. Several jurisdictions, including Arizona, Illinois, Ohio, and Nevada, have pursued cease-and-desist orders or litigation against Kalshi, while tribal nations in multiple states have brought claims asserting violations of the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act. At the same time, Kalshi has secured favorable rulings in select federal courts, contributing to an uneven and still-developing legal landscape.

Claire

iGaming & land based specialist reporter for the global gaming market

Recent Posts

Banijay Gaming Posts €778 Million in Q3 Revenue as Tipico Effect Kicks In

Banijay Gaming reported third-quarter revenue of €778 million, an increase of 18% year on year,…

13 hours ago

Playtech Shares Rollercoaster As Evolution Reaches Settlement

Shares in Playtech experienced a period of pronounced volatility after it emerged that Evolution AB…

16 hours ago

Australia’s Regulator Issues Guidance on Blocking Payments to Illegal Gambling Sites

The Australian Communications and Media Authority (ACMA) has published guidance outlining how banks and payment…

19 hours ago

New Jersey Gaming Revenue Reaches $649.5 Million in October

Total Gaming Revenue for casinos, racetracks, and their partners in New Jersey reached $649.5 million…

19 hours ago

Pennsylvania Posts All-Time Monthly Gaming Revenue Record in October

Pennsylvania's regulated gaming industry recorded its strongest month in history in October 2026, with the…

20 hours ago

Utah Sues Stake.us Operators, Alleging Illegal Online Casino Operation

The State of Utah has filed a civil lawsuit against Sweepstakes Limited and Easygo Group…

20 hours ago