New York Sports Betting Handle Grows Despite Prediction Market Pressure

New York’s regulated sports betting market continued to expand through 2026, even as federally regulated prediction markets such as Kalshi and Polymarket intensified their competition for sports wagering volume. The sustained growth challenges claims from prediction market operators that state-licensed sportsbooks are losing meaningful share, while the state simultaneously pursues legal action against at least one major platform.

Handle Trends Remain Firm

New York, the largest sports betting market in the United States, posted $26.3 billion in mobile sports betting handle in 2025, an increase of approximately 15% over the $22.7 billion wagered in 2024. That momentum carried into 2026. September mobile handle reached $2.40 billion, up 5% year over year, and the state has recorded consecutive months with handle above the $2 billion mark.

The summer months were particularly strong. July handle rose 34.3% year over year on a $1.88 billion base, following a 36.6% increase in June. Together, the two World Cup months generated approximately $4.1 billion in wagers. July also delivered an 11.4% hold for operators, producing $214.4 million in gross gaming revenue from eight online sportsbooks.

State fiscal year 2026 figures reinforce the market’s contribution to public coffers. Mobile sports betting generated $1.3 billion in state tax revenue, driven by New York’s 51% tax rate on gross gaming revenue – the highest in the nation.

The Prediction Market Challenge

The growth comes against the backdrop of a widening dispute between state regulators and prediction market platforms. On July 31, New York Attorney General Letitia James sued Kalshi in Manhattan, alleging the platform operates an illegal gambling business through its sports event contracts. The suit seeks a minimum of $36 billion and cites estimates that prediction market evasions of state and tribal law have siphoned more than $1.2 billion in gaming tax revenue nationwide. Governor Kathy Hochul has backed efforts to shut down prediction market operations in the state.

Kalshi has disputed the characterization. According to the company, roughly 70% of its daily trading volume comes from sports markets, and it maintains that its contracts are federally regulated financial instruments rather than wagers subject to state gambling laws. Prediction markets also operate under a lower federal tax structure than state-licensed sportsbooks, a discrepancy that has become a central point of contention for the regulated industry.

Limited Cannibalization, Industry Data Suggests

Available data indicates the competitive impact on licensed operators has so far been modest. Analysis of tracking data by Juice Reel, cited in industry reporting, found that only about 4% of regulated online sportsbook handle has permanently migrated to prediction markets. Industry analysts have also observed that the threat appears to be easing rather than accelerating, with handle trends in early-reporting states remaining stable.

About the Author

Light&Wonder Advertisement